The BBQ Beat Podcast

The BBQ Beat Podcast
  • BBQ Product Reviews
  • BBQ Buying Guide
  • BBQ Recipes
  • Podcast Archive
  • Join the Community
  • Watch on YouTube
Home » Best Masterbuilt Electric Smokers: My Top 3 Picks Reviewed Here

Best Masterbuilt Electric Smokers: My Top 3 Picks Reviewed Here

By Kevin Sandridge

Masterbuilt-Electric-Smokers-Review-Header

Looking for the best Masterbuilt electric smokers for you and your family? You’ve come to the right place.

Crafting a great barbecue experience takes time, care, and attention to detail. Whether you’re looking for that perfect pulled pork sandwich, or you’re dreaming about some super succulent BBQ ribs, the right equipment makes all the difference.

This guide to the best Masterbuilt smokers I’ve tested will put you on the right path.

Masterbuilt Electric Smokers Overview

Masterbuilt’s history of building electric smokers dates back to 1973. This Christian-based and family-run company represents one of the longer-standing brands in the electric smoker product category. Their longevity and focus on customer satisfaction count for something in my book.

Masterbuilt Electric Smokers – Built on Faith, Family, and Hard Work

If you’re anything like me, you’re a fan of seeing hard work and American ingenuity combine with faith and family to produce quality products. This is the history of Masterbuilt Electric Smokers. Starting with Dawson McLemore, a backyard project given steady attention eventually blossomed into a thriving business.

As part of this Masterbuilt Electric Smokers review, I want to give you a little background on the company. To that end, here’s a brief history of the founding of Masterbuilt Smokers…

Take a look at the video below, and you’ll quickly see the work ethic put to use to eventually bring the best Masterbuilt electric smokers possible to market.

Masterbuilt Electric Smokers Review

Average Cost

Masterbuilt electric smokers are manufactured to give you acceptable smoked food results at a price that won’t break the bank. When I say this, I mean that the base units average a cost of between $100 and $400. Most of the units mentioned in my pellet smoker reviews post start at around the $400 range. So, you can see where you are in terms of cost here.

A Note on the Pricing of These Smokers

Pricing for Masterbuilt Electric Smokers remains relatively low. Understand, this is because they’re made overseas. Realizing that you may be someone who prefers to buy American Made products and shy away from those made in say, China, you should consider this point.

Durability and Value

If kept covered and out of the elements, your Masterbuilt electric smoker should last a long time. The lower end units are not meant to be daily use workhorses, but the average cooking volume of these electric smokers doesn’t allow for high volume anyway. 

These electric smokers are meant for average-sized families who enjoy smoked food.

Maintenance and Clean Up

As with any smoker, the prep work you do up front makes a ton of difference in how much work you wind up doing after the cook. Many users report that placing your meat in disposable aluminum pans or at least, placing one at the bottom of your Masterbuilt electric smoker will catch drippings and keep clean up at a minimum.

These are widely used ‘tricks’ even among seasoned BBQ pitmasters. I always cook my pork butts in aluminum pans, and it makes all the difference in the world clean up-wise. Oh, and using aluminum pans won’t impede the smoke getting into your meat.

Getting Smoke Flavor with Masterbuilt Electric Smokers 

Please understand that regardless of manufacturer, electric smokers produce food that has mild to medium smoke flavor at best. You’re not cooking on a concrete block or brick pit here. It’s a small unit that’s meant to give you some smoke flavor with minimal “care and feeding.”

You can possibly amp up your smoke levels by selecting woods like hickory, oak. or pecan. Fruit woods like apple, peach, and cherry produce relatively mild smoke flavors.

Best Masterbuilt Electric Smoker Models

Below are my top 3 picks for inclusion in this Masterbuilt Electric Smokers review. I’ve ordered them by features and average cost.


Masterbuilt 20070210 30-Inch Black Electric Analog Smoker

This is Masterbuilt’s best electric smoker for the entry-level user. It has three smoking racks – giving you a good amount of space. The variable thermostat temperature control lets you set the smoking temperature to your desired reading with ease, and the unit’s built-in thermometer keeps it running at the setting you choose.

Best Masterbuilt Electric Smokers

The smoker includes an interior wood-chip tray and water pan. This Masterbuilt electric smoker represents the company’s intro model. It’s bare bones, but it does the job. On thing to note here is that you have to open the cabinet up to add smoke chips. As such, you’re going to lose a bit of heat when doing so. Other models below feature an external wood chip chute that allows the main cabinet to remain closed during refueling.

Masterbuilt Analog Electric Smoker: Features and Benefits

The Masterbuilt 20070210 30-Inch Black Electric Analog Smoker is a true cooking and smoking unit, in that the temperature setting runs from 100 – 400 degrees F. Clean up is relatively easy, especially if you smoke your meats in disposable aluminum  pans.


Masterbuilt 20070910 30-Inch Black Electric Digital Smoker, Top Controller

A step up from its analog cousin, the Masterbuilt 30-inch electric digital version is the best electric smoker for those wanting to gain a bit more overall cooking control. As you can see, the cabinet smokehouse style is still in use, but Masterbuilt adds in digital controls for greater temperature accuracy and an external wood chip feeding system.

Best Masterbuilt Electric Smokers

The digital temperature settings panel does offer a 24 hour timer that provides an automatic shut off so your food won’t overcook. The ability to feed wood chips into your electric smoker means that you don’t have to open up the main cabinet and lose all that heat and smoke when refueling.

This 30-inch electric digital smoker with top controller has a temperature range of 100 – 275 degrees F. This is important to note in that you won’t be able to do any hot and fast smoking at this rate. That said, these lower temperatures are perfect for BBQ as well as cooking fish or making jerky.

Smoked BBQ Wings on the Masterbuilt Electric Smoker

Overall, I feel that the addition of the digital controls and the external chip feeding feature make the Masterbuilt 30-inch digital smoker a great purchase. 

This electric smoker boasts a good amount of interior space, with four racks that give you a little more than 730 square inches of cooking area. Between this and the unit referenced above, I’d probably go with this one for the chip feeding feature alone. Learn more about the Masterbuilt 30-inch digital smoker here.


Masterbuilt 20075315 Front Controller Smoker with Viewing Window and RF Remote Control, 40-Inch

Of the three smokers I reference in this review article, the 40 inch model here with RF remote control is my pick for best Masterbuilt electric smoker.

In addition to the extra cooking space provided and the external fuel/wood chip feeding chute seen in the previous model, you get some great added functionality.

Best Masterbuilt Electric Smokers

The 4 rack system for this smoker feature curved back ends on each rack that allow you to slide the racks out half way and are ‘caught’ so they don’t tip out. This feature functions much in the same way as the racks do in a standard kitchen oven. Trust me, when you least expect it… those racks are gonna come in handy!

The other feature I like is that there’s a nice sized internal drip tray that has an “overflow” that feeds out to a rear-mounted external drip tray. It seems like Masterbuilt has put years of testing and trials into the thought behind this model, making it not only large in capacity, but extremely function and easy to use.

Masterbuilt 40-Inch Digital Smoker with RF Remote Features Video

Here’s a video of a nearly identical unit – Masterbuilt’s Top Control 40 inch digital smoker with RF remote. The features of this smoker are the same.

I am not always a bells and whistles fan, but when looking for the best Masterbuilt electric smokers, the remote here being RF-based is a nice plus. The rack system and drip tray layout make for easy operation and cleanup, and there’s a built-in thermometer that users report reads internal meat temperatures accurately. All in all, it really seems that for not that much more money, you’re getting a functional and well-thought-out unit.

Learn more about the Masterbuilt 40-inch digital electric smoker with RF remote here.

Best Masterbuilt Electric Smokers: Final Thoughts

In writing this Masterbuilt Electric Smokers review, it’s clear to me that the company has done a great job of crafting reliable and easy to use electric smokers that provide consistent results.

The base model I reference in this review will do the job for a single person or small family. Obviously, you get more cooking space with the 40-inch models.

If bells and whistles are for you, definitely consider the Masterbuilt 40-inch Front Controller Smoker with Viewing Window and RF Remote Control. It’s got all the features you’ll need for easy smoking and clean up.

Remember, that if you go with any model of electric smoker that requires you to lift the lid or open the door to the main chamber, you’re going to experience a serious dip in smoke and thermal temperature. For that reason alone, I’d lean towards models that provide an exterior fuel feeding chute or mechanism.

Have You Found This Post Useful? Have a Question? Please Ask!

If you’ve found this Masterbuilt Electric Smokers review post useful, please share it with others you feel might also enjoy it. Have a question? Please ask in the comments area below! As you can see from my pellet smoker reviews post, I’m pretty good at getting back to you!

Related

Tags: Best Electric Smokers, Best Masterbuilt Electric Smokers, electric smoker from masterbuilt, Electric Smokers, Masterbuilt Electric Smokers, Masterbuilt Electric Smokers Review Categories: BBQ Product Reviews, Electric Smoker Reviews

Prev
Next

Comments

  1. Kevin Sandridge says

    at 1:51 PM

    Hi Brown, have to say your experiences with Masterbuilt Smokers shocking folks is troublesome. I see reports that they had a problem in this area on “some” units, but not for the past 3 years or so. I see that you, yourself, are recommending Masterbuilt Smokers on your own site, so you surely know that they are a solid buy. Thanks for stopping by.

    Reply
    • Rick Rowbotham says

      at 4:07 PM

      I’ve been reading and some reports are saying the digital controls are not as good as the older models

      Reply
  2. Ted says

    at 5:23 AM

    Great article and awesome advice. Thank you

    Reply
    • Kevin Sandridge says

      at 5:37 AM

      Thanks, Ted!

      Reply
  3. Brittany says

    at 2:49 AM

    Hi my boy friend just bought the 30 in. Smoker byge says that we can also use it as a refrigerator. I told him no you can’t it just looks like a refrigerator, I looked it up and found nothing. Who’ s right?

    Reply
    • Kevin Sandridge says

      at 7:45 AM

      Ha! I’m inclined to side with you on this one. If you want a mini fridge, just buy a mini fridge. 🙂 In truth, the structural elements of a well-insulated electric smoker are similar to a fridge in many respects. But, that’s pretty much where thing end.

      Reply
  4. Walter says

    at 1:52 PM

    I just got into an argument with someone……he is trying to tell me that u can use the digital electric smoker indoors …mind u he lives in an apartment…I saw no …who is right

    Reply
    • Kevin Sandridge says

      at 2:43 PM

      Hi, thanks for your comment. In short, no. You should not use any smoker indoors. Restaurants and some high end homeowners may be able to do this with professionally installed ventilation systems. But, again, for the vast majority … like 99.999% of cases, the answer is a firm no.

      Reply
  5. Jennifer says

    at 6:30 PM

    So would the mes 130s just be a smaller version of the 140s? Or does the 140s contain more features too? I’m thinking about the 140s, but would like a smaller version…

    Reply
  6. Jennifer says

    at 6:40 PM

    Hi. So is the 130s just a smaller version of the 140s? Or does the 140s contain more features? I am liking the 140s, but I am wanting a smaller version…thanks!

    Reply
    • Kevin Sandridge says

      at 6:54 PM

      Correct. The 140s Give you a bit more room inside. Honestly, I would go with the 140. You never have to use all of the space, but if you ever need more space you’re kind of stuck. It’s not that much more of a size jump to the 140.

      Reply
  7. Nancy says

    at 9:35 AM

    An informative article. Masterbuilt smokers are indeed one of the best ones. Thank you for a great share

    Reply
  8. Doug Sobel says

    at 12:36 AM

    Have you tried the new series 400 smokers? I’m looking at the new generation 40″ smoker

    Reply
    • Kevin Sandridge says

      at 7:40 AM

      Hey Doug – No, I have not, but I need to! Hope to have a chance to investigate and get a review up soon!

      Reply
  9. Jim Rust says

    at 12:07 PM

    I bought an electric smoker just last year. The Masterbuilt model MB25075517 used it about 10 times and when I unplugged one of the electric prongs that comes from the heating element came off with the plug.I do not leave the smoker plugged up the plug stays inside except when in use and the smoker has been covered with a tarp except when in use. The thermometer never worked correctly I just bought another one rather than worry about a $2 part. I can replace the element if I could find a way to order the thing but Masterbuilt does not give a way to contact them except through their site and then only for warranty purposes. I guess I just own a piece of junk now I have been on their web page for the last 45 minutes trying to contact them but no way. I guess I’ll just have to go find another one from a manufacturer that cares about their customers after the warranty runs out.

    Reply
    • Kevin Sandridge says

      at 12:02 AM

      Hello Jim, thank you for taking the time to comment here. I am very sorry to hear about the issues you’ve faced with your Masterbuilt electric smoker. I’ve reached out to Masterbuilt and they assure me that if you contact them via their social media channel – in this case their Facebook page by sending them a message – you will receive a response. You can find that page here: https://www.facebook.com/masterbuilt/

      Reply
      • Jim Rust says

        at 9:24 AM

        thank you but I have already replaced it. I have been in customer service most of my life and when I have to jump through hoops to contact any company that I buy their product I do not have any patience, in my mind it seems all they are concerned with is the initial sale. So thank you for your help but like I said I fixed the problem by eliminating it. Thanks again, Jim

        Reply
        • Kevin Sandridge says

          at 12:56 PM

          Understood. Thank you for being part of the community here all the same. I do appreciate your input!

          Reply
          • Lagean Ellis says

            at 2:49 PM

            We have replaced our thermostat 2x and it’s still not quite right. We still can’t regulate the temperature correctly. It’s kind of hit or miss. The first thermostat went out after about one year or a little over. It was easier to replace than worryl with Masterbuilt. We reported the issue. We just can’t seem to get a good read on the temperature, even when the thermostat is new.
            It’s now too old to mess with so I’m getting him a new one this month for his birthday. We have the glass front and have decided not to go that route, purely because it gets so nasty that we can’t see through it and, living in the country sure doesn’t help.

        • Scott Slinde says

          at 12:23 PM

          I completely agree what company doesn’t have phone customer services

          Also no gasket under the digital controller mine shorted out after moderate rain though I bought their brand of cheap ass cover for it

          Reply
  10. Joe says

    at 11:31 AM

    Thanks for you advice – I am looking for my first Masterbuilt smoker and was wondering if the top broil feature was worthwhile. If it is, a suggestion on the model that includes that feature?

    Reply
    • Kevin Sandridge says

      at 4:57 PM

      Hey Joe! I’m not quite sold on the broil feature as being a ‘must have.’ If it comes on a model you find that you like, great! But I probably would not let it be the deciding factor.

      Reply
  11. David Brown says

    at 7:16 AM

    Very important reason behind seasoning the Masterbuilt Propane Smoker is rust prevention. Despite the multiple solvents and coatings applied inside this vertical smoker, there is nothing that can safeguard your Masterbuilt Propane Smoker against rusting.David Brown famous for delicious smoker recipes, expert cooking methods, cooking tips, and tricks as well as for his cooking recipes

    Reply
  12. judy nessen says

    at 5:36 PM

    Trying to decide between the Masterbuilt 30″ digital electric smoker (aluminum) and the 30″ digital electric smokehouse (steel). Same good reviews, same price. Which do I go with?

    Reply
    • Kevin Sandridge says

      at 7:27 PM

      Hello Judy! I’d probably go with the steel one. The aluminum model “might” get up to temp faster, but the steel version would be my pick for holding temps evenly over longer cook times.

      Reply
  13. Rick says

    at 5:55 PM

    Hi, Can you put pellets in the bin instead of wood chips?

    Reply
    • Kevin Sandridge says

      at 2:43 PM

      Hi Rick! Sorry for the delay in my response. No, sir. Please only use the chips they direct you to use.

      Reply
  14. Paul says

    at 4:43 PM

    If someone can help me out. I can’t get enough smoke in my Masterbuilt. I have had three smokers and never had this problem this bad before. I have always been told and always kept my wood chips soaked. I am wondering if I should stop soaking the chips so they will burn and smoke better.

    Reply
    • Kevin Sandridge says

      at 6:25 PM

      I’d definitely try not soaking them.

      Reply
  15. Roger Barkley says

    at 6:15 PM

    What is the difference in using electric or propane for fuel. Pros and cons.
    Thanks

    Reply
    • Kevin Sandridge says

      at 6:27 PM

      Both will allow for easy lighting and heat management. Cons for both is that you are limited in terms of getting wood fired flavor you’d get over charcoal.

      Reply
  16. Robert Steve says

    at 2:20 PM

    Thanks Kevin for Sharing detailed information related to this topic.

    Reply
  17. Estela says

    at 6:29 PM

    Hello, We are new to the use of a smoker and appreciate the advice. Can you please give me the model numbers for the two digital smokers you recommend?
    Thank you!

    Reply
    • Kevin Sandridge says

      at 2:13 PM

      I’d recommend the OG Grilla or their Silverbac as a starting point. GrillaGrills.com

      Reply
  18. Brad Lee S Martin says

    at 2:46 PM

    My smoker keeps throwing up a air after getting it set to cook it starts beeping and it doesn’t stop until you turn it off and reset and do everything again it will not keep smoking What do I do

    Reply
  19. Bill Heerschap says

    at 7:38 PM

    I am looking to buy a first smoker. Can someone tell me the difference between the Masterbuilt 140S and the 140G???
    And how long does a cup of chips last???

    Reply
  20. Richard Brenner says

    at 8:45 PM

    I’m looking at purchasing a Masterbuilt 20070910 30 inch digital electric smoker. Can this unit be stored outside if I keep it covered and waterproofed when not in use?

    Reply
    • Kevin Sandridge says

      at 5:32 AM

      Hey Richard, I don’t see why not.

      Reply
  21. Pete Parker says

    at 11:46 PM

    I like the concept but their electronics are worthless! This is the third controller I have replaced. I keep it under cover but the NW winters and moisture destroy the electronics. The glass window is a complete joke. Who ever came up with that idea deserves the Darwin award for stupidity. They need to seal up the electronic control unit or make it easily detachable so it can be stored inside.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get Podcast Updates!

Don't miss a new BBQ Beat Podcast episode! Simply fill out this form, and I'll make sure you're updated as soon as a new one goes live! #BBQBEAT
You Have My NO SPAM Guarantee!

Cook like the Champions

  • Razorracks BBQ on Winning Big with a Small Footprint
    Razorracks BBQ - Drew Davis
  • Duce Raymond of Sweet Baby Ray’s
    Duce Raymond Sweet Baby Ray's
  • Black Smoke: African Americans and the United States of Barbecue
  • Ted Reader on Making it Tasty with Live Fire
    Chef Ted Reader
  • Chris Becker of CookinPellets.com
    Chris Becker CookinPellets
  • Amy Mills – BBQ Business and the Legacy of Mr. Mike
    Amy Mills 17th Street BBQ
  • 2021 Hog Drop Champion John Lindsey
  • Rusty and Anthony of the Pitmasters Podcast
    Pitmasters Podcast
  • Montana Max on Food Sport and His BBQ Champs Academy Series
    Montana Max BBQ Champs Academy
  • Protecting Knives in Style – Talking with Mick Kerkham of Maka Leathergoods
    Interview with Maka from Maka Leathergoods

See BBQ Relief in Action!

Help Operation BBQ Rescue

Best Wireless Alarm

Listen to the Podcast!

BBQ-Beat-Podcast-275x275
The BBQ Beat Podcast
Follow on
Twitter
Connect on
Facebook
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
Copyright © 2023 The BBQ Beat Podcast