The culture of Carolina BBQ dates back to at least the 17th century. It is steeped with traditions including the famed Eastern Carolina vinegar sauce or mop and the art of cooking whole hogs over pits fired with wood coals in proverbial low and slow fashion.
Promoted largely through the 1800s by German immigrants who spread their love of pork across the Carolinas, especially North Carolina, Whole Hog cooking morphed to a preference for cooking shoulders as you move to the Lexington, NC area.
Barbecue in the Carolinas has, sadly, begun to shift and change with the times, but in some select locales, there are traditionalists old and new who are shunning gas and electric cooking means in favor of using just wood, fire, smoke, and time.
In this podcast episode, I talk with John Shleton Reed about Carolina BBQ history, where BBQ sits today both regionally and nationally, and what he and his compatriots are doing to preserve the Southern Tradition of Barbecue.
John Shelton Reed is a true Southern gentleman scholar. He grew up in Kingsport, Tennessee, studied at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, and received his Ph.D. from Columbia University. His books and writings covering the history and culture of the south can be found across more than twenty books covering the subject, not the least of which includes Holy Smoke: The Big Book of North Carolina Barbecue and his most recent BBQ related text, Barbecue: a Savor the South Cookbook (Savor the South Cookbooks).
He has been a Guggenheim Fellow, a Fellow of the National Humanities Center, and twice a Fellow of the Center for Advanced Study in the Behavioral Sciences. He has lectured at over 300 colleges and universities in the U.S. and abroad, including a number of universities in India as a Fulbright Distinguished Lecturer, and he has held visiting positions at many institutions, including the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, the Institute of United States Studies at the University of London, and All Souls College, Oxford University.
He spent 1996-97 at Cambridge University as the Pitt Professor of American History and Institutions and Fellow of St Catharine’s College. He taught for some years at the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, retiring in 2000 as William Rand Kenan Jr. Professor of sociology and director of the Howard Odum Institute for Research in Social Science. He helped to found the university’s Center for the Study of the American South and the quarterly Southern Cultures.
Episode Summary




In this podcast episode, I talk with John Shleton Reed about Carolina BBQ history, where BBQ sits today both regionally and nationally, and what he and his compatriots are doing to preserve the Southern Tradition of Barbecue.
During this exploration, John and I discuss the nature and history of Carolina Barbecue and some of the early figures who helped put this style of low and slow pork cuisine on the map. We also discuss the state of barbecue today, competition BBQ – related to the Kansas City Barbeque Society – and what that means for BBQ culture, and branch out to refer to other barbecue styles, namely Texas-style barbecue.
What You’ll Discover
- The origins of Carolina barbecue from Eastern to Western Carolina and on into South Carolina
- How John become acquainted with Carolina-style barbecue and came to author his epic history on the subject
- Where and how hush puppies became standard side items at Carolina barbecue joints
- The impact German immigrants made on barbecue in the Carolinas
- Just how closely linked the two predominant style of North Carolina barbecue are to one another
- How competition barbecue is helping spread the love of barbecue, so long as you like it Kansas City-style
- The origins of Mustard Sauce and why you don’t want to use it if you’re competing, no matter how much you love it
- Where there’s great “transplant” barbecue in Downtown San Francisco – cooked on all wood, no electric or gas
- What North Carolina’s tourism board can learn from Texas when it comes to supporting and promoting its unique barbecue tradition
- How you can earn instant appreciation from TrueCue.org approved pitmasters, just by asking to see their pits
People, Places, and Things of Interest
- John Shelton Reed
- TrueCue.org
- John’s Books on Amazon.com
- Center for the Study of the American South
- Southern Cultures Quarterly
Complimentary Podcast Episodes
- Episode 009: Christopher Prieto of PRIME Barbecue on Success in BBQ and Life
- Episode 007: Talking Local Food in Kansas City with Local Pig Founder Alex Pope
- Episode 017: David Stidham of A Fine Swine BBQ on Bringing Competition Cue to the Masses
Questions, Comments or Suggestions?
Have a question or a podcast guest suggestion? Please leave me a message on my contact page. You can also find me on Twitter and via the BBQ Beat Facebook Page.
Be Sure to Listen to More Episodes!
If you enjoyed this episode of the BBQ Beat Podcast, you can see the full podcast archive here. Or, simply catch up on some of the other most popular BBQ podcast conversations listed below.
- Razorracks BBQ on Winning Big with a Small FootprintTalking with Drew Davis of Razorracks BBQ about how teams without big rigs, toy haulers, or trailers can still win big on the competition BBQ trail! Topics discussed include the importance of having the right mindset, tips for making the most out of your team’s competition dollars, and much more. Keep Reading »
- Duce Raymond of Sweet Baby Ray’sIn this episode, I talk with Duce Raymond of Sweet Baby Ray’s about the origins of the world’s most popular barbecue sauce. But we go way deeper than that. Duce shares the origins of the iconic Sweet Baby Ray’s sauce, but he also details how one very important lesson from his uncle continues to drive the family’s successful restaurants and catering business forward. Keep Reading »
- Black Smoke: African Americans and the United States of BarbecueIt was my great pleasure to sit down for a chat with James Beard Book Award Author Adrian Miller to discuss his latest book, Black Smoke: African Americans and the United States of Barbecue. A true scholar, historian, and lover of smoked meats, Adrian and I talk about the contents of this text, along with the reasons he felt it needed to be written. Keep Reading »
- Ted Reader on Making it Tasty with Live FireNo one embodies the spirit of crafting amazing food with live fire better than Canada’s Chef Ted Reader. I can’t thank Teddy enough for sitting down and allowing me to record this EPIC chat! Keep Reading »
- Chris Becker of CookinPellets.comChris Becker founded CookinPellets to make the best premium BBQ pellets available. Join me for an in-depth look at how and why he did it. Keep Reading »
- Amy Mills – BBQ Business and the Legacy of Mr. MikeAmy Mills of 17th Street BBQ shares loving memories of her Dad, Mr. Mike Mills, the impact COVID has had on their business, and more. Keep Reading »
- 2021 Hog Drop Champion John LindseyIn this episode, I talk with John Lindsey of All Q’ued Up BBQ about his recent Grand Champion win at the 2021 Hog Drop held at the Jack’s Old South compound in Unadilla, GA. Keep Reading »
- Rusty and Anthony of the Pitmasters PodcastRusty Monson and Anthony Lujan host the Pitmasters Podcast… and they are on a mission to ignite the passion of cooks everywhere-from amateur to pro-to continue to exceed their own expectations on their journey to Master the Pit! Anyone who loves cooking with live fire and the fun and fellowship of BBQ should make the […]
- Montana Max on Food Sport and His BBQ Champs Academy SeriesGreat chat with food sport professional Montana Max about his new ancillary classes offered up on BBQ Champs Academy! Keep Reading »
- Protecting Knives in Style – Talking with Mick Kerkham of Maka Leathergoodswith “Maka” Kerkham from Maka Leathergoods in Tasmania. His leather knife rolls are sought after by top chefs and BBQ pitmasters worldwide. Keep Reading »
Leave a Reply